Bueno voy a volver a mis viejos tiempos de posts en inglés. La idea es mandarle todo lo que surja en este post como feedback al equipo de desarrollo de Plurk, juntando mi review con los comentarios de quienes quieran aportar. Así que si saben inglés, dejen sus comments sobre Plurk en este post!
Lets see:
Since yesterday I’m using Plurk, a new microblogging system that I consider very interesting. Sincerely twitter had me pissed off for some time now, because of its lame functioning.
The idea behind Plurk is let you share updates ala twitter, images, videos and such; but ordered on a timeline by order of appeareance from left to right. And as it doesn’t have as many users as twitter, it works smooth now..
Being using it so little, gave me a couple of ideas that would be interesting to see applied. Also, many “Plurkers” provided their opinions to share. Here are some of them:
User Interface
Timeline: Although the timeline feature is a very original way to show updates, some people find it annoying (not my case). Maybe there should be an option to let you choose wether to see updates on timeline, or in a stream like in twitter or jaiku.
Timeline orientation and position: Some users find hard to read updates from left to right. That should be customizable. Also, maybe a slider that allows us to drag the timeline height, to better see all our contacts “plurks”.
Timeline data and scroll: If you scroll waaay back to another day, you’ll realize that nothing indicates you that you’re on a different day. Also, if you’d like to go way back on the same day, you’ll have to scroll a lot. There should be an optional scroll bar that helps you to move faster.
User Profile: This is a little bit odd… you don’t have enough information from each plurker in order to decide to follow him or not. It’ll be nice to have a basic profile, and then another one with more information available.
Plurks: Sometimes there are a lot of conversations that you don’t want to follow, but you keep receiving updates from them. A very important feature will be the ability to un-follow some conversations that way you don’t get bothered by alerts.
Social
Plurkers: It’s really hard to follow or add new plurkers-friends to you profile. There should be a way to search for them by Screen Name, and then add them.
Another way to do so, would very simple: When you see someone’s comment, and you realize that you’re not following that person, you should be able to click on their screen name, and have an option to follow, or to add as a friend (among the other options that you have at the moment). That’ll do the job of having all your friends on Plurk, a lot easier!
IM & SMS: Some users told me they were experiencing some problems with the GMAIL and Hotmail integration. I’ve personally not used this feature, but that’s something to be checked out. Also there are some features as follow users and other things that are not being provided thru SMS service.
Well, those are some of my comments on these first days of use of Plurk, sure the development team will improve a lot of things as soon as they start getting some feedback from users, just like this post.
One thing I think they should really be working on is on the social aspect: twitter (or jaiku or similars) have a very strong adventage: community.
I’ve mentioned that there is no easy way to add friends or followers using Plurk. That should change immediately. If you don’t allow users to socialize and to create their own community inside Plurk, users will tend to leave the service and go back to what they are used to play with.
I don’t think that Plurk can take real advantage on twitter’s poor performance at the moment.. twitter is a huge monster, hard to defeat, but I believe that Plurk has some pretty good features that should be exploited at their maximum.
Don’t you have a Plurk account yet? Create one and add me as your friend!

















falta el tema de las hotdancers en los costados (?)
Good Job! Congratulations
Si si, pablito, pienso = q vos…sobre todo el tema del listado de registrados…pero bueno, es recien el comienzo y hay q ver si nos acostumbramos a este nuevo sistema, si hace algunos cambis para q sea más práctico, si vamos a usar twitter y Plurk al mismo tiempo, si elegimos usar solo uno de los 2, etc……..¿?…yo, x ahora, ya estoy muy metida en twitter, va a tener que hacer muuuucho Plurk para que me atrape al 100%….y bueno…veremos……muy buen post!! bastante completo!!
PD: a los que esten en plurk, agreguenme: /user/agospiana
I agree with you. The system to add friends is complex . It performs better than twitter (except the limit of 140 characters). Pownce also has and does not exist. Why? Because twitter has: Community. Everything else comes alone.
Negativo:
Sera un buen ejercicio para la vista pero el scroll horizontal no es una buena práctica de usabilidad. Para seguir una conversación tenés que ir barriendo arriba-abajo-arriba…
Los mensajes largos están replegados > Puntero arriba de cada caja para desplegarlo.
Karma = Juguete . Te doy los chiches si invitas mas amiguitos.
Falta de integración (o no lo encuentro) con feeds externos como si lo hace jaiku y FriendFeed.
Positivo
El contador de mensajes pendientes en la solapa / titulo de la página.
Los thumbnails y las vistas de videos / fotos en la misma pagina sin tener que navegar a un sitio externo a plurk.
Kadrianus: “Para seguir una conversación tenés que ir barriendo arriba-abajo-arriba…”
No, para eso tenés los replies en cada update.. Lo del scroll pura y específicamente sirve para ubicar cronológicamente los posts..
Lo de los feeds es cierto.. y la integración de las fotos y YouTube son muy positivos!
Jorge: If your community starts going somewhere else because of the lack of quality of your service.. then you’re in trouble!
Agos! Muchas gracias! Obviamente que le falta.. pero por el momento me llama mucho más que jaiku o Pownce..
Ya veremos como sigue…
Juanu: Grax!
j0an: jajaja, bizarra la sugerencia, no!?
Well… talking about the user interface, for me is a little bit tiresome at times, I prefer the twitter UI like, because is easier to read the updates, you just put your eyes on a column and on Plurk you have to move your eyes all around the screen for read a conversation, for me a column like twitter’s timeline would be a good alternative for the users.
Looking for friends/plukers, as the paranoid person I am, the email/im contacts importer seems to be a bad choice for me. I’ll love Plurk if you add a search form, or an easy way to add new plukers, just clicking on his updates, it’s annoying right now, you must see the user’s profile before adding him, remember the KISS, you should keep that in mind.
I hope you find my words useful :).
One more thing, I would like the option to make private my updates, I don’t want to see Google indexing what I’m saying.
You already have that. Check “Plurk privacy & options” under the update box on your profile..
Es cierto que se puede contestar directamente en la caja de un plurk(?). => Dos lugares distintos para escribir (No me cierra entonces).
Algunos seguirán utilizando el clasico @ (que en plurk funciona tambien pero no encadena los comments a los ‘plurks’ referenciados (como en jaiku) pero si hiperlinkean con el usuario a la derecha del arroba y aparecen como un update tradicional en la timeline.
Pablo, i don’t think so, I have the options:
- The whole world
- Only (Type the name of the friend or clique)
- No one, this is only for myself (WTF?)
And as the lazy I am.. I want the option “only my friends”, if I have hundreds of plurk contacts I don’t want to type all the names there…
Finally, the text “it’s [HOUR] and…[NICKNAME]” are in black… always, so if I choose the black or another dark background the color of that text doesn’t change, that means black word over a black/dark background… ¬¬
Xyborg: Go to your profile settings, Privacy, you’ll find these options:
Allow the whole world to view my plurks
Allow friends and friends of friends to view my plurks
Allow only my friends to view my plurks
Only I can view my plurks
Ah.. I thought it was at the section below the textbox area. (Plurk privacy & options). Thanks a lot :), now I can rest in peace XD
Muy buena review!
y conoci tu blog gracias a esta imagen:
http://www.mix.pe/contenido/una-imagen-vale-mas-que-1000-palabras
saludos!
me reuslto una herramienta complicada y muy rebuscada, si bien su interface es interesante, es demasiado pedir para el usuario.
de todas formas, si sale una api para adobe air la pruebo.
de todas formas, me quedo con twhirl de twitter.
y esto es para los que les gusto plurk:
http://www.twistermc.com/blog/2008/06/04/plurk
Ahora me está gustando más la idea de poder tener micro-conversaciones en Plurk, al poder responder a algún comentario en particular, y todos pueden agregar algo, en ese mismo comentario, hace el dialogo mas ordenado…
Mal que no pusiste fotos nuestras en pelotas.. Mal mal..
Prefiero el castellano, no entiendo un pomo
Plurk needs a link for every plurk (including the ones nested in conversations).
Also, it would be a nice idea that it alerts you of updates in the conversations you’ve already participated, not every response in your timeline.
↑ Volver arriba